Cindy Caine, (otherwise known as SINdy), was the daughter of Albert Caine, and the unused icon for Halloween Horror Nights: Islands of Fear. Originally, each island at Islands of Adventure was meant to convey that everything was part of Cindy's disturbed mind, with every Scareactor and creature part of her "playthings". The story of Cindy was changed due to the fact that there was a string of child abductions at the time and was replaced with The Caretaker. Later, she became to be known as his daughter in later works starting with Screamhouse: The Resurrection. She was also meant to be a part of the backstory for Halloween Horror Nights: Twenty Years of Fear, but the idea was scrapped. She is a Morphan like H.R. Bloodengutz and Jack.
- Screamhouse: The Resurrection (2006)
- Shadows from the Past (2009)
- HHN: 20 Years of Fear (2010)
- The Orfanage: Ashes to Ashes (2010)
- Jack Presents: 25 Years of Monsters & Mayhem (2015)
- ICONS: HHN (2015)